What happened

Jon Vanstone, chair of the Industry Competence Committee (ICC), warned that subcontractors who acknowledge gaps in their competence for safety-critical work could be removed from projects. He made these remarks during a session at the Building Engineering Services Association's (BESA) annual conference in London, according to Construction News.

Vanstone’s comments addressed the practice in heavily subcontracted markets, where admitting limitations may result in firms being replaced instead of getting help to rectify competence shortfalls. He highlighted concerns that correcting failings after the fact does not address underlying causes, stressing the need to focus on decision-making that leads to defective work.

Vanstone said the ICC has already provided guidance for clients on competence, but further work is needed to understand how contractual terms influence a firm's ability to meet competence requirements.

Derry Building Services director Brian Hughes provided additional insights at the event, noting that contractual and deadline pressures might discourage site workers from halting work to question problems. He pointed specifically to fire-stopping as an area where variations from design can occur in practice. Hughes warned that if workers do not record deviations from plans, specialist contractors can face exposure in case of disputes.

The background

The discussion follows the introduction of new dutyholder and competence requirements for building safety, which came into force under the Building Safety Act) in October 2023. These rules place clear obligations on organisations and individuals to demonstrate competency and address unsafe building practices.

Tyler Felix, senior legal and commercial adviser at BESA, explained that contractual requirements now frequently require organisations to assure client teams that their staff are competent and have fulfilled their dutyholder responsibilities. Some contracts also demand that companies keep workers' competence under review throughout projects and provide evidence beyond academic certifications, including competence assessments and ongoing obligations.

A recent BESA-commissioned survey by Barbour ABI found that 91 per cent of respondents said their organisations could show compliance with the new dutyholder requirements. However, 36 per cent reported difficulties in actually demonstrating competence on site, while 74 per cent saw little change in client behaviour since the new rules took effect.

According to the survey, fewer than half (43 per cent) of organisations used formal competence assessments for verification, while 90 per cent relied on qualifications and certifications for workers.

What people are saying

Vanstone advocated for competence management to be based on the roles and actual tasks, rather than on individual workers alone. He said contractors should see any change, such as product substitutions, as a prompt for additional scrutiny. He added that the industry needs to tackle how commercial contracts might impede competence improvement, noting that further ICC guidance is planned on this issue.

Brian Hughes told the conference that main contractors or clients might hold specialist subcontractors responsible if things go wrong, cautioning that a lack of evidence over site deviations can impact their liability. Hughes outlined steps Derry Building Services takes to address these risks, including prequalifying subcontractors, sharing quality-assurance systems, and tracking worker qualifications, although he noted these procedures have not been tested by regulators so far.

Tyler Felix pointed out that competence is an ongoing requirement, rather than a single check at project start. She said BESA is analysing contractual wording to help limit risks associated with competence obligations, as contracts increasingly demand proof of ongoing compliance.

BESA chief executive David Frise told Construction News that association audits sometimes uncover discrepancies between written policy and actual practice among member firms. BESA’s Competence Assessment Standard (CAS) includes independent and periodic assessment of technical competence and commercial capability, with failure leading to potential suspension from membership.

In January, BESA said it suspended five member firms after audits found failures to meet CAS requirements, a figure added to 14 suspensions made in 2025. Frise highlighted how fast-paced working culture in the sector can undermine efforts to embed best practice.

What happens next

Vanstone said the ICC would continue work on guidance to address contractual issues affecting competence. BESA is reviewing how contracts can better protect firms and ensure that competence obligations do not become a source of new commercial risks.

The new Building Safety Act rules require ongoing compliance, not just initial checks. As industry groups and regulators audit firm practices, evidence of competence and quality control is likely to become more critical. According to BESA, firms failing to keep up with competence standards may risk losing membership or work opportunities.

Companies will increasingly be expected to maintain documented, auditable systems for verifying and updating workforce competence in response to task changes or project variations.