What happened

On 27 March 2018, a pallet of bricks fell from a tower crane at a residential construction site on Burdett Avenue, Bow, east London. The falling bricks struck Michaela Boor, 28, who was passing by the site. Boor died two days later, which was the day after her 29th birthday.

Higgins Homes was both the client and the contractor for the project. The incident led to multiple charges including corporate manslaughter for Higgins Homes, and gross negligence manslaughter for individuals connected to the project. The Old Bailey began hearing the case in November 2023. The trial has entered its sixth week and is due to last for four months.

Court proceedings reported by Construction News revealed that the prosecution claims Higgins Homes used generic construction management and phase plans which contained factual errors and omissions. Craig Hook, the prosecution's expert witness in construction and lifting operations, gave evidence about inadequacies in the project’s health and safety documentation.

The prosecution alleges these failures contributed to safety risks at the site. Higgins Homes, along with the accused individuals, have all pleaded not guilty to the respective charges against them.

The background

The incident involved a residential scheme in east London where Higgins Homes acted as both principal contractor and principal designer. The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 and the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations (CDM) 2015 are key frameworks for health and safety at such sites.

Craig Hook told the court that documentation on the job did not meet required standards. He identified that the construction phase health and safety plan included placeholder text such as “PCI to be inserted”, which referred to pre-construction information that was never finalised. The tables identifying people at risk from site-specific issues were incomplete.

Hook said the health and safety plan referenced a nearby road, Booker Close, in contradictory ways, and referred to features such as mast climbers and a slew limitation system that were not used on this site. The plan also referenced both the now-superseded CDM 2007 regulations and the 2015 version, leading to inconsistencies.

Hook argued that the plan should have been specific to the risks and equipment at the precise location. Instead, he described the plan as insufficient for managing site risks. The site’s traffic management plan also cited features like one-way traffic management, onsite parking, and a wheel washing station, none of which existed on the site. One access configuration was outlined from "Saxon Way", but the court heard that no such road exists near the project.

Earlier, the court saw emails from November and December 2016 between Higgins Homes and London Tower Cranes. These showed that initial plans included pedestrian gantries and equipment—such as anti-collision systems—to restrict the crane’s movements. According to Hook, these features were shown in pricing quotes but were not included in the actual order. There was also no pedestrian gantry installed, contrary to preliminary site diagrams.

What people are saying

Craig Hook, as the prosecution’s expert witness, told the court that health and safety documents should be tailored to the site and the exact activities taking place. He gave examples such as “PCI to be inserted” and incomplete risk tables as evidence that the documents fell short. The documents, he said, referenced out-of-date regulations and included measures and controls that were not ever used at the site. Hook noted that, while the construction phase plan had revisions, these were not accompanied by an independent risk check or adequate monitoring.

Prosecuting barrister Alexandra Healy KC questioned whether the plan met regulatory requirements for revision and adequacy under the CDM 2015 regulations. Hook said that despite being revised, there was no effective scrutiny or test of the plan’s adequacy. Hook described a process in which documents appeared to have been approved at a surface level but did not provide fundamental details for safe site management.

On the specifics of the lifting plan and site set-up, Hook said that quotes from London Tower Cranes included a gantry and safety technology, but these precautions did not appear to be implemented. Later plans and photographs did not show the gantry present on-site, and the anti-collision and camera systems cited were not taken up in the order for equipment.

Higgins Homes and the four individuals accused in the trial have all pleaded not guilty. The individuals are:

  • Dawood Maan, crane supervisor, charged with gross negligence manslaughter and breach of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.
  • Alexander McInnes, crane operator, facing the same charges.
  • Thomas Anstis, senior site manager and temporary works coordinator for Higgins, also charged with gross negligence manslaughter and breach of duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act.
  • Stephen Coulson, director of Coulson Lifting Services and the appointed person responsible for the lifting plan, charged with the same offences.

What happens next

The trial at the Old Bailey continues and is scheduled to last four months. The hearing is now in its sixth week. The prosecution continues to present its evidence and call witnesses. Cross-examination and defence presentations are expected to follow.

The focus of the case is the adequacy of health and safety planning, risk management and implementation of controls for tower crane and lifting operations on the Bow site. The results may highlight the role of specification, design and ongoing oversight in construction safety, especially concerning public safety around operational sites.

A verdict is not expected before spring 2024. Outcomes could have regulatory, reputational and operational consequences for the parties involved and are likely to be closely followed across the UK construction and cladding sector. The trial is ongoing and no findings on liability have yet been made.