What happened
Research carried out by retrofit contractor Domna indicates that the growing use of procurement frameworks is allowing contractors to charge housing associations above-market rates for retrofit work. According to Domna’s published report, the proliferation of frameworks has not led to competitive pricing. Housing associations are said to be facing higher costs, alongside restricted abilities to renegotiate pricing after contracts are awarded.
The report calls for significant changes in how such contracts are awarded, including the introduction of fewer, mandatory government-run frameworks and increased open-book contracting. Under open-book contracting, contractors disclose their actual costs and profit margins. Domna says this would provide greater transparency and enable more effective cost control.
The background
The current market for housing retrofit frameworks includes commercial providers, charities, and public bodies. Domna's report describes this market as fragmented, with some commercial framework operators charging fees or commissions to suppliers participating on their framework. Contractors are often selected on the basis of their paperwork submissions, rather than evaluated against the actual cost or quality of their completed work.
Many frameworks operate on a basis of agreed unit prices over five-year periods. Once these are set, housing associations have limited ability to negotiate if market prices change. According to Domna, contractors can recover their margins through contract variations or call-outs. The company also points out that agreed prices are not always routinely checked against current market rates.
Domna carried out benchmarking for one unnamed housing association. It found price premiums of 93% above market rates for low-energy lighting supply and installation, 87% for thermostatic radiator controls, 79% for internal wall insulation, and 78% for cavity wall insulation.
What people are saying
Anna Moore, chief executive of Domna, argues that every pound spent on duplicated work or overpriced contracts is money lost that could be used to further improve housing stock. She adds that procurement changes could improve the efficiency and overall results of public retrofit investment.
The report also includes assessment from Dan Germann, managing director of residential regeneration contractor Durkan Regen. Germann calls for early and transparent discussions about project costs, design, and risks, suggesting that parties should agree on what each home actually requires and set a sensible target cost before any work is undertaken.
Domna’s report advocates for a smaller number of government-led frameworks, with better-resourced public sector procurement teams and a move towards assessing contractors by their completed work rather than bid documentation.
The numbers
Domna's benchmarking estimates suggest that some housing associations are paying nearly double the market rate for certain retrofit works. The report calculates that procurement, contract pricing, and improved project planning could save the social housing sector around £2 billion per year.
One example cited in the report is a retrofit project that was originally forecast to cost £2.8m, with an average of £21,000 per home. After individual assessments, the projected total fell by nearly a third to £1.9m, reducing the median cost per home to £14,000.
What happens next
Domna is recommending the creation of fewer, mandatory government-run frameworks and wider use of open-book contracting. The company also calls for greater investment in procurement skills within the public sector. The report suggests that adopting these recommendations could result in significant savings for social landlords.
Framework operators, contractors, and housing associations will need to review their procurement practices and monitor future responses from government or other industry bodies. The issue of fragmented frameworks and inflated costs is likely to remain in focus as energy-efficiency retrofit targets and public scrutiny over value for money continue.
